Thinking about moving to a new username because NO ONE CAN SPELL THIS ONE, except me. D: Thoughts/ideas/cupcakes?
And now for the MAIN EVENT, some epic wankery/asshattery/wtfisthis!
I opened my DA inbox to find
Jateshi's journal entry on the one and only Diana Gabaldon, author of the
Outlander series of books (which I have never read). She linked to
this fandomwank post which summarily
links to Ms. Gabaldon's blog post in which she BAAAWWS about fanfic authors and how they are immoral. And wrong. And rapists. And possibly pot heads growing marijuana in some random guy's backyard. it's a pretty long read, full of wtfformatting, so allow me to summarize it for you:
Ms. Gabaldon does not like fanfiction. She thinks fanfiction authors are doing illegal things, like rape and murder and stealing from people's brains. She also thinks there is an International Copyright Law (Honey? There isn't. No, really, there isn't.) AND THIS MAKES MY BRAIN HURT:
One real easy way to find out. Write anything you want, using Jamie Fraser, Edward Cullen, Harry Potter _and_ Dr. Who….and then change the characters’ names before you post it. Simple. Find All: “Jamie Fraser”. Replace with: “Joe Kerastopolous”. No problemo, all your own work, and any praise you get is duly earned.
Okay, guys, I have a new novel idea! It's about this guy named Bobby Alan, who is raised by his aunt and uncle, Veronica and Joe, and lives with his cousin, David! But they really suck and they're mean and they make fun of him for the squiggly scar on his shoulder. But then one day they start getting tons of E-mails and so they start running around only than this huge guy named Nathaniel shows up and tells Bobby he's really a wizard and he gets to go to the Salem School for Magic! And I'll call it
Bobby Alan and the Mirror of Bad Fortune, 'cause it'll involve a mirror. Yeeeaaaah.
Of course, the fact that it's basically the plot of Harry Potter means nothing, because I replaced all the names! Oh, god, my sides, they hurt. Ms. Gabaldon: FANFICTION IS NOT WHAT YOU THINK IT IS.
Ms. Gabaldon also thinks that somehow, fanfiction is moral if the author is dead and the work is in the public domain. This is such a double-standard I don't know where to begin, because technically, it's still "stealing" (her words, not mine), right? Are you suddenly okay with fanfiction of your characters after you're floating around in Whatever Ghostly Plane May or May Not Exist? Excellent! I'll just find a way to live forever, read your doorstops of books, and write fanfiction all I want!
6) But I just looove your characters! And isn’t imitation the sincerest form of flattery?
Weeeelll…let us just say that there’s a difference between someone dating red-haired men, and the same someone trying to seduce my husband. LOL so okay from what I've heard she based her character Jamie off of her husband, right? So already, she basically wrote real person fanfic (and real person fic gives me all sorts of squicks, but whatever floats your boat) AND she suddenly gets her panties in a wad from someone writing sexual fic using him. YOU DUG YOUR OWN GRAVE, HUN.
About that “privacy of your own imagination” thing….[cough] While not all fan-fic is pornographic by any means, enough of it _is_ that it constitutes an aesthetic argument against the whole notion.
As I say, I’ve unwillingly read a certain amount of fan-fic involving my characters, and about three-quarters of it is graphic, badly-written (of the “his searing touch blazed its way up the silken skin of her thigh to the secret depths of her ecstasy” type) masturbatory fantasy. I mean….ick. I think this is funny because from what I hear, her books are full of self-grafitying porn. I hear tell of Jamie (I think?) getting nailed to a table and then anally and orally raped. Also of this Claire character running home to her first husband with Jamie's seed all over her legs (!?) and other stuff of that nature. So she gets squicked by reading porn using her characters, but she's perfectly okay with writing it. Hey, lady, if you didn't base your characters off people you know you wouldn't have this problem! This is just too funny.
Also, can I point out that she says she "unwillingly" read this fanfic? Lady, no one's making you read it. lol.
But…imagine opening your daily mail and finding a letter detailing an explicit sexual encounter between, say, your twenty-one-year-old daughter and your forty-eight-year-old male neighbor---written by the neighbor. At the bottom it says, “Fiction! Just my imagination. All cool, right?” This would perhaps prevent your calling the police, but I repeat…ick. As one person said, it's more like clicking your way to your neighbor's blog, clicking past the 18 and over warning, only to find it. You don't really just "inadvertantly" find porn fic because almost every author who writes fic PUTS UP A SEXUAL CONTENT WARNING. If you ignore it, it's your own fault.
Also, your characters are fictional. It's not like having sex with your daughter or seducing your husband because THEY ARE FICTIONAL. If you're that attached to your characters and you feel a mental blow when someone touches them in any way, you maybe need some meds.
So far, Ms. Gabaldon has compared fanfic authors to stalkers, rapists, vandals, adulterers, horticultural thieves, and slavers. If she wanted to piss off the entire community of fandom people, she did an awesome job. Because writing fanfiction is totally like selling your children into sexual slavery. Oookaaay....
Well as you all know this all comes from something Ms. Gabaldon found using fanfiction: a charity auction involving fan-made pieces using her characters and Twilight characters. The auction would be to raise money for a girl named Stacie dying from cancer. Now I don't quite agree with selling pure fanfiction (there is a difference between actual fanfiction and parodies or satires like
Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, a fact Ms. Gabaldon misses as she calls it fanfiction) but it's for a good cause and it's not like they're using the money to go party. Sakky has sold the original sketches of some of her fan pieces to raise money for Sara Baker, a girl from the Tower of Time (a Sailor Moon forum I frequent) who was involved in a car accident and now suffers from locked-in syndrome. It was a way to raise money, and no one was hurt by it. Naoko Takeuchi, the creator of
Sailor Moon, did not lose money. Ms. Gabaldon is not losing money because of someone writing fanfiction. So I ask: what is the big deal?
Of course, her constant screaming of "COPYRIGHTCOPYRIGHTCOPYRIGHT!" does not work as well as she thinks it does, because copyright does not cover everything. There's the Fair Use clause, and oftentimes exceptions are made for transformative works, like fanfiction. Fanfic is in a gray area; it's not illegal. If Ms. Gabaldon hates it that much, she can just say "Hey dudes don't write fanfic okay?" and pretty much all fanfic authors will not write fic because they do this out of love for what they're a fan of, and respect for its creator. For example, I love Robin McKinley's book
Beauty, but she has spoken out against fanfic so I don't write fanfic about Beauty. It's that simple.
Imitation is the highest form of flattery and I would be ECSTATIC if I ever found fanfic using my work. It proves that someone cared enough to read the whole thing in-depth enough to expand it with their own ideas. Tolkien himself loved fanworks, saying
"I would draw some of the great tales in fullness, and leave many only placed in the scheme, and sketched. The cycles should be linked to a majestic whole, and yet leave scope for other minds and hands, wielding paint and music and drama." The authors posting on Ms. Gabaldon's blog agreeing with her in the form of "I DON'T KNOW WHAT FANFIC IS BUT I DON'T LIKE IT, THEY NEED TO DIE" and
issuing challenges like Eddie Louise's apparently have some insecurity because they are that worried about an innocent fan pasttime that has existed for AGES. Dude, if you're that worried, just ask people not to, we're not going to be that devastated. Oh, lol, this is just too much to deal with this early in the morning. So much stupidity.
Can I just say that I think it's funny that she has such a problem with derivative works? THE PARTY'S OVER, GUYS! NO MORE SHAKESPEARE! NO MORE DANTE! NO MORE MOVIES OR GAMES BASED ON BOOKS OR OTHER THINGS! NO MORE KARAOKE! IT'S ALL OVER! Because Diana Gabaldon said it was immoral, and Her Word Is Law. Except for the part where it isn't.
My new manifesto with my work: GIVE ME FANFIC. I want your smut, your Mary Sues, your bad English, I WANT IT ALL, BBY. Give me something based on When the Stars Fade (If I ever get that monster finished) where Aisling is replaced by Alexandra and falls in love with Kotone or whatever. I HUNGER FOR IT. And I don't base my characters off people I know, so go wild with the sex.
And when I finally get published I will wear my fanfic author badge proudly because it helped me and I know that many fans are the salt of the earth. They're what keeps something going. If you don't have the support of fans you are totally screwed, so EXCELLENT JOB ALIENATING YOUR FANS MS. GABALDON. I know I'm not reading Outlander now.
I don't know about you, guys, but I'm itching to write and read some fanfic. Maybe I'll write some Star Wars smut with Obi-Wan and Siri. And maybe trawl through the Percy Jackson Hole of Bad Fanfiction on FF.net. What say you? Recommend me some stuff. :B
ETA:
My wishes have come true and Ms. Gabaldon has
posted a follow-up entry in which she is trying to attempt damage control and not sound so pissy. I suspect that if she hadn't stepped into the hornet's nest, she wouldn't be having this problem. Just sayin'.
I was hoping she'd bring up the Berne Convention as her explanation for that strange "International Copyright Law" because that is most definitely what it isn't. An International Copyright Law would imply something universal and uniform. The Berne Convention is not universally accepted, and it still makes exceptions for Fair Use, Creative Commons, and LOOKIE HERE, derivative works. So LOL Gabaldon, your International Copyright Law thing, wherever it exists, still does not protect you.
Copyright is kind of overrrated anyways, why do I care about it after I die. lol. I wonder if there's some way to say "AFTER I DIE, MAKE IT PUBLIC DOMAIN!"?
I'm really fuzzy right now and I forgot how boring it can be reading the Berne Convention (Hey, look, I actually read the thing) so I may be a little wrong in the above paragraph, but jeez.
I'm a little surprised that no one has brought up the issue of writing fanfiction using original characters. This is something I do. Am I still not a "real writer"? Or am I suddenly one because I use OCs? But that would be a double standard! BALL IS IN YOUR COURT!
(I love how we call it "real writing" if it's not fanfic. What, so they're not actually writing, they're just making pretty pictures? It's like when companies say they're using real cheese, not fake stuff. So you're not using plastic cheese? Okay, so maybe it's genetically "enhanced" but we still call it cheese. Ergo, fanfic writers are still real writers. Just...lol.)
Also, I have to agree with all the people calling her out on being an insensitive bitch (I apologize, sort of) and trvializing the pain of sexual assault victims and then not apologizing, but finding the time to put in a plug for some random tea named after her characters. Fail, Gabaldon! I hereby revoke your internets.